Poll: Which Pokémon Game Really Deserves A Remake Next?

Deep within the whimsical world of Pokémon, the whispers of remakes have long stirred excitement among devoted fans. With the recent revamps of beloved classics like ‘Pokémon FireRed’ and ‘Pokémon Omega Ruby,’ the nostalgia is palpable, and anticipation is running high. The question on every Trainer’s mind: which iconic Pokémon game truly deserves a remake next?

As we await the next big announcement, we invite you to join us on a journey through the vast expanse of the Pokémon universe. From the sun-kissed shores of the ‘Alola’ region to the mystical landscapes of ‘Hoenn,’ the possibilities are endless, and the choices are as varied as the Pokémon themselves.

So, buckle up and get ready to have your say in our latest poll. Will you champion the rebirth of a classic 2D adventure, or will you vote for a 3D escapade that will transport you to new heights? The power is in your hands, Trainers. Cast your vote and join the conversation: which Pokémon game really deserves a remake next?

Rethinking the Classics

The Pokémon community has been ablaze with rumors and speculation about the next remake, but one thing’s for sure – some games are more deserving of a facelift than others. Long-time fans and critics alike have weighed in on the matter, and here’s a breakdown of some of the top contenders:

• Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver – the beloved Johto remakes have been at the top of many wishlists since their original release on the DS. With updated graphics and gameplay mechanics, a modern take on the classic tales could bring new life to the franchises’ iconic regions.
• Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire – these GBA titles laid the groundwork for 3D Pokémon games but have yet to receive a modern remake. Their unique storylines and underwater exploration mechanics make them strong candidates for a reboot.
• Pokémon Crystal – the first Pokémon game to feature a female protagonist, Crystal has long been a fan favorite. Bringing this game up-to-date could not only appeal to nostalgic audiences but also serve as a great entry point for newcomers.

In recent years, Nintendo has re-released classic titles with new graphics, gameplay mechanics, and enhancements, met with enthusiasm by both critics and fans. How the next remake will shape up, however, is anyone’s guess. Here’s how our poll respondents weighed in on their top pick for the next Pokémon remake:

Game Title	Percentage of Votes
Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver	30%
Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire	28%
Pokémon Crystal	24%
Other	18%

Clearly, our respondents have some strong opinions on the matter – but which classic game do you think deserves the remake treatment? Let us know in the comments below!

A Look Back at Past Remakes

The world of Pokémon remakes has seen its fair share of iconic re-releases, each bringing a fresh spin to beloved classics. Notable mentions include Pokémon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire, remakes of the 2002 Game Boy Advance titles, which introduced 3D visuals and new gameplay mechanics to the series. Similarly, Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver revamped the 1999 games, boasting an upgraded interface and seamless integration with Nintendo DS systems.

Other notable remakes include:

• Pokémon: Let’s Go, Pikachu! and Let’s Go, Eevee!, which rebooted the 1998 Pokémon Yellow game.
• Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, remakes of the 2006 Nintendo DS games.
• Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen, upgraded versions of the 1996 games.

We can analyze the evolution of Pokémon remakes in a more organized way by examining a selection of these re-releases and their unique features:

Game Title	Release Year	New Features
Pokémon FireRed	2004	Improved graphics, more Pokémon species available
Pokémon HeartGold	2009	Touch-screen controls, DS mini-games
Pokémon Omega Ruby	2014	3D graphics, Hoenn region, new Pokémon
Pokémon: Let’s Go, Pikachu!	2018	Casual gameplay, Joy-Con integration

Fan Favorites and Overlooked Gems

Some of the most popular Pokémon games that have yet to receive a remake include:

• Pokémon Colosseum: The GameCube classic that introduced 3D battles and a unique storyline.
• Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness: The sequel to Colosseum, which continued the innovative 3D battling style.
• Pokémon Mystery Dungeons: Red Rescue Team: A roguelike spin-off that gained a dedicated following.
• Pokémon Ranger: A unique action-adventure game that showcased a differing gameplay style.

Additionally, there are a few Pokémon games that may not be on everyone’s radar but still have their own devoted fan base:

A few overlooked gems that could potentially receive a remake include:

Game Title	Release Year	Unique Features
Pokémon Pinball Mini	2001	Portable pinball game with unique stages and Pokémon interactions.
Pokémon Channel	2003	Experimental TV-broadcasting game with a strong focus on exploration.
Pokémon Conquest	2012	Crossover strategy game with the Nobunaga’s Ambition series.

Would any of these titles make it onto your remake wishlist? Or do you think there’s another classic Pokémon game that deserves a remake next?

The Case for Pokémon Colosseum

Pokémon Colosseum is often overlooked when discussing the need for a remake. However, the case for updating this GameCube classic is a strong one. One of the most compelling reasons is its unique storyline. Here are some reasons why we think Colosseum should be remade:

• Its narrative, centered around the Orre region and its sinister organizations, offers a fresh take on the traditional Pokémon formula.
• A remake could help flesh out the region and its inhabitants, drawing parallels with other games in the series.
• The story’s focus on redemption, loyalty, and the blurred lines between good and evil would provide players with a richer, more complex experience.

A remake would also allow the game to take advantage of modern hardware, facilitating smoother gameplay and more realistic graphics. The concept of ‘snagging’ Shadow Pokémon could be reworked, potentially using a new mechanic such as:

Feature	Potential Reworking
Snag Machine	Use it to disrupt opponents’ strategies by converting their Pokémon to Shadow type.
Shadow Pokémon	Add an additional ‘Corrupted’ type, dealing bonus damage to its own allies.
Purifying Pokémon	Attach a purification progress bar, with increasingly difficult steps to heal the Pokémon.

By modernizing these mechanics, a remake could breathe new life into the series, opening the door to new gameplay opportunities and plot developments.

Reviving a Sleeping Giant in Pokémon XD

The beloved GameCube game Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness often gets overlooked in discussions about remake-worthy titles. However, this unusual gem deserves a second chance in the spotlight. With a unique storyline, intriguing characters, and an addictive gameplay mechanic, a remake could bring this dark horse back into the fray.

While it may not have been as commercially successful as some of its contemporaries, Pokémon XD has a dedicated fan base, thanks in part to its engaging gameplay and memorable characters. Here are just a few reasons why a remake could breathe new life into this classic:
*

Unique Features	Remake Possibilities
Shadow Pokémon	A deeper exploration of the Shadow Pokémon system, complete with new Pokémon and abilities
Character-Driven Storyline	An expanded narrative, delving deeper into the backstories and motivations of characters like Michael and Jovi
Innovative Gameplay Mechanics	Updated battle systems and innovative uses for the Snag Machine, potentially incorporating modern Pokémon features

If a remake were to happen, it would undoubtedly bring a fresh wave of excitement to fans of the original. By updating its unique features and characters for a modern audience, Pokémon XD could finally get the recognition it deserves as a true classic in the Pokémon franchise.

Why Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire Deserve Another Shot

Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire, released in 2002 for the Game Boy Advance, brought significant innovations to the franchise, such as the introduction of double battles, multiplayer capabilities, and a more developed storyline. However, despite these advancements, the third generation has often been overshadowed by other installments in the series.

One of the main reasons Ruby and Sapphire stand out is their unique region, Hoenn, which boasts diverse landscapes, from the humid Mauville City to the scorching deserts of Route 111. The games also introduced new features, including the Primal Kyogre and Groudon weather system and the ability to hold items. Both of these have had a lasting impact on the series.

Main Features that Made Them Innovative:

• Double Battles
• Multiplayer Capabilities
• A More Developed Storyline
• Primal Kyogre and Groudon Weather System
• Ability to Hold Items

Comparison of Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire with their Remake:

Pokémon Games	Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire	Pokémon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire
Release Year	2002	2014
Console	Game Boy Advance	Nintendo 3DS
Regional Features	Introduction of Hoenn Region	Enhanced Hoenn Region with 3D Graphics

Assessing the Chances of a Pokémon Mystery Dungeons Remake

Diving Deeper into the Chances of a Revival

Considering the resurgence of interest in classic Pokémon spin-offs, a Pokémon Mystery Dungeons remake seems increasingly plausible. A well-crafted remake could potentially tap into the nostalgia of old fans while introducing the series to a new generation of gamers. However, several factors must be taken into account to assess the chances of such a project.
Some of the factors include:

* Previous remake success
* Audience demand
* Development priorities
* Technological limitations

Possible Pokémon Mystery Dungeons Remake Features	Enhanced Storytelling
Improved graphics and sound design	Character backstories and development
New characters, Pokémon, and gameplay mechanics	Increased difficulty levels and replay value
Remastered music and sound effects	Characters’ emotional journeys and arcs

A potential remake would likely build on the success of Pokémon Mystery Dungeons: Gates to Infinity and Pokémon Super Mystery Dungeons, incorporating new features to set it apart from previous games.Fans have long been speculating about a remake, and while there’s currently no concrete evidence to support these claims, a revival of the series would be well-deserved and much appreciated by enthusiasts worldwide.

Community Response and What It Reveals

From all the Pokémon games, the ones that have failed to receive remakes until now are catching more attention, with Diamond and Pearl topping the remake wish list for some, and Ruby and Sapphire for others. There’s also a group of fans who think Black and White should be prioritized. Clearly, this hasn’t just been about gamers choosing favorites from a list, each one has their reasons because of their different styles, and many want the classic style to return. Some players have identified as those who love the gameplay of these classic ones, even if the games were simple compared to some of the new ones. Interestingly, people say more classic Pokémon games should return before even any sequels or additions to modern Pokémon series, giving insight into the nature of gaming preferences and past experiences.

	Percentage
Should the next remake be of the classic generations (I-III)?	54%
Those who love the Pokémon games don’t always want a retro-style game	27%
Most Pokémon series gamers expect sequels in the future	22%

• Sequels could have newer in-game graphics
• There could also be the possibility of returning some previously used older mechanics that make the games nostalgic but ‘fresh’
• Yet, with many players admitting not everyone follows gaming trends and more modern Pokémon games
• Even remakes could possibly draw gamers into trending remakes that might take old players back to the times when a different type of Pokémon game was the fashion

Comparing the Storytelling of Older Games

Storytelling in older games often feels more subtle and less “in-your-face” than in modern titles. A big part of this is due to the limitations of older technology – with less power to render fancy cutscenes or voice act every line of dialogue, developers had to be more creative in how they told their stories. The original Pokémon Red and Green games, for example, used a combination of text-based storytelling and environmental clues to paint a picture of a world where Pokémon and humans coexisted.

This sense of subtlety and restraint can actually be quite refreshing, especially in games that are more focused on gameplay than on storytelling. The Crystal games, for example, added some optional side quests and extra storylines, but the main point was still the same: to catch ’em all and become the Pokémon Master. Other examples of storytelling in older Pokémon games include:

Game	Storytelling method	Results
Gold and Silver	Text-based storytelling	A sense of discovery and exploration
Ruby and Sapphire	Environmental clues	A richer, more immersive game world
FireRed and LeafGreen	A combination of both	A more engaging and interactive experience

1. Offer a sense of discovery and exploration
2. Create a more immersive and interactive experience
3. Use a combination of text and environment to tell the story

Weighing the Technical Feasibility of a Potential Remake

When considering a remake, it’s not just about nostalgia, but also about the technical feasibility of bringing the game up-to-date. The Pokémon series has had its fair share of remakes in the past, but some games are more challenging to update than others. For instance:

• Graphics-intensive games like Pokémon X and Pokémon Y would require significant updates to run smoothly on modern hardware, including improved 3D rendering and polygon counts.
• Classic games like Pokémon Red and Pokémon Blue might require more fundamental changes, such as updating the battle mechanics and game engine to bring them in line with modern Pokémon games.

Additionally, the following table provides a rough estimate of the technical complexity involved in remaking some of the popular Pokémon games:

Game	Graphics Complexity	Game Engine Complexity	Battle Mechanics Complexity
Pokémon Red and Pokémon Blue	Low	High	Medium
Pokémon Yellow	Low	Medium	Low
Pokémon X and Pokémon Y	High	Medium	Low

Examining a Potential Remakes Impact on the Franchise

A remake can be a double-edged sword for a beloved franchise like Pokémon. On the one hand, it allows a new generation of gamers to experience a classic game, while also giving the original creators a chance to update the game to modern standards. On the other hand, a remake can also alter the player’s perception of the original game, and the franchise as a whole.

When deciding which Pokémon game deserves a remake next, it’s essential to consider the impact it will have on the franchise. Here are some key factors to think about:

• Fan demand: Which game do the fans want to see remade the most?
• Storyline: How important is the game’s storyline to the overall Pokémon narrative?
• Gameplay mechanics: Are there any outdated mechanics that need updating?
• Replay value: Will the remake bring new players to the franchise, and will they stay?

Potential Remake	Original Release Year	Potential Benefits
Pokémon Ruby/Sapphire	2002	Updated Hoenn region, new features, and improved battle system
Pokémon Diamond/Pearl	2006	Revamped Sinnoh region, new multiplayer features, and enhanced graphics

Considering these factors will help you decide which Pokémon game truly deserves a remake next. Cast your vote and join the discussion.

Final Thoughts

As the Poke Balls continue to bounce and battles rage on, the eternal debate lives on – which Pokémon game truly deserves the remake treatment next? The games that didn’t make the top spots will have to wait a little longer, their loyal fan bases eagerly holding out hope. The Pokémon world is vast and full of possibilities, and one thing’s for sure – no matter which game gets remade, the unbridled enthusiasm of fans will drive the fire that fuels the next legendary adventure. The poll may be closed, but the conversation is just beginning. Share your thoughts with us – which Pokémon game do you believe truly deserves a remake? The next Pokémon master piece is just around the corner…